Indictments just the beginning

Photo by: AFP
Co-investigatorsYou Bunleng and Marcel Lemonde announcing the indictment of former Khmer Rouge leaders yesterday at Cambodia’s war crimes tribunal.

via CAAI

Thursday, 16 September 2010 20:46 James O'Toole and Vong Sokheng

THE Khmer Rouge tribunal capped a three-year investigation yesterday by issuing formal indictments for four regime figures, setting the stage for the court’s second trial to begin in the first half of next year.

The four – former Khmer Rouge head of state Khieu Samphan, foreign minister Ieng Sary, social action minister Ieng Thirith and Brother No 2 Nuon Chea – face charges including genocide and crimes against humanity.

They are alleged to have helped mastermind a regime under which as many as 2.2 million Cambodians died, 800,000 violently, according to a demographic survey produced in the investigation.

French Co-Investigating Judge Marcel Lemonde – responsible, along with his Cambodian counterpart You Bunleng, for directing the investigation – said it was “a more complex case even than the Nuremberg Trials” for former Nazi leaders, with the case file extending to more than 350,000 pages.

“We make absolutely no claim at all that we have written the definitive history of the Khmer Rouge era,” Lemonde said at a press conference yesterday. “What we have done, however, is to establish the fundamentals, the framework, for a high-level judicial debate, which we expect to be conducted in public.”

Prosecutors have 30 days to appeal against the closing order, and defence lawyers will likely move to raise challenges as well. The court’s Pre-Trial Chamber must rule on such appeals within four months before the case is sent to the Trial Chamber.

International co-prosecutor Andrew Cayley said in June that the court’s second trial would stretch “at least two years”.

Court observers say Case 002, with four defendants and four defence teams vigorously contesting the charges against them, will be a significantly more complex affair than the tribunal’s first case, that of former S-21 prison chief Kaing Guek Eav. The infamous Khmer Rouge jailer, better known as Duch, was found guilty in July of crimes against humanity and grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions, receiving a 30-year jail term.

“S-21 was a closed circle, and it went on for a long time,” historian David Chandler said last year. “Duch said he did it, and the documents said he did it. These guys say: ‘We didn’t do it,’ and there are no documents, so it gets much trickier.”

A total of 3,988 people applied to participate as civil parties in the case, after just 90 civil parties participated for the duration of the Duch trial.

Of these, 2,123 have been accepted so far in Case 002, though a number of rejections have been challenged.

Lemonde said he and others at the Office of the Co-Investigating Judges had faced challenges as they sought to balance the need to begin proceedings against the ageing defendants as quickly as possible with the need to establish a comprehensive case file.

One such difficulty emerged prominently last year as King Father Norodom Sihanouk and six ruling party officials ignored summonses seeking their testimony at the court.

“In spite of the difficulties and obstacles – and I can tell you, they were not small ones – we have succeeded ... in producing a document which will allow a trial that Cambodians have been waiting for for 30 years,” Lemonde said.