Tuesday, 9 November 2010

Cambodia fronts UN torture commission


Photo by: Heng Chivoan
A guard looks out from a watchtower over Prey Sar prison

via CAAI

Monday, 08 November 2010 20:09 Chhay Channyda and James O’Toole

Five days after being arrested and charged with robbery, Heng Touch was sent to Prey Sar prison.

When his mother and brother visited him the next month, they learned that he had fallen ill; guards recommended that he be transferred out of his overcrowded cell, but demanded US$200 in exchange. The family could not afford to pay, and on a return visit, after learning that Heng Touch’s condition had worsened, his mother discovered bruises on his head, face and limbs and cuts on his tongue.

Heng Touch’s mother paid $30 to have him transferred to Monivong Hospital, where he later told her he had been viciously beaten by five men, sustaining lung damage and a fractured skull. Little more than six weeks after being incarcerated, Heng Touch died at Calmette Hospital.

This 2008 incident is documented in a report that was compiled by local rights groups ahead of Cambodia’s appearance today before the United Nations Committee Against Torture in Geneva, and the problems it illustrates – prison overcrowding, impunity for law enforcement, a lack of recourse for alleged torture victims – are sure to be high on the committee’s agenda.

“The situation of torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment in Cambodia is still of concern,” the rights groups said in a joint statement. “The country’s legal and judicial system is unable to effectively prevent and punish acts of torture.”

Cambodia ratified the UN Convention Against Torture in 1992, but is up for only its second review before the committee; the last was in 2002.

Although torture is punishable by up to 15 years in prison under the Kingdom’s new penal code, a difficulty in prosecuting such cases is the fact that “torture” is not clearly defined. The government said in a briefing to the CAT submitted ahead of Tuesday’s meeting that such a definition is not necessary because Cambodia “abides by the principles of international conventions”.

Am Sam Ath, a technical supervisor for local rights group Licadho, said his organisation had recorded 108 reported cases of torture in police custody in 2009 and 101 in the first 10 months of 2010. Despite these figures, the rights groups said in their report that they knew of no instances in the last five years in which law enforcement officials accused of torture had been prosecuted.
Ministry of Interior spokesman Khieu Sopheak dismissed the allegations contained in the report.

“This report was written only to satisfy donors and get their money, so it is not true. It is an accusation against our police,” Khieu Sopheak said. “To arrest a thief does not mean to welcome that thief to sleep like a guest in a prison.”

Among their recommendations for improving Cambodia’s record on torture, the rights groups suggested the establishment of a civilian body to process torture complaints and greater use of bail to ease overcrowding in the prison system, which was operating at 173 percent of capacity as of June. The groups also called for the closure of controversial “Social Affairs Centres”, where sex workers, children and the homeless are often detained without due process, and where reports of abuse are widespread.

The meeting in Geneva comes just two weeks after government officials threatened to close the UN human rights office in Phnom Penh. Foreign Minister Hor Namhong backed away from these statements last week, saying there was “no decision to close this office yet”.

12 comments:

  1. http://acquistarecialisgenerico40mg.net/ comprare cialis online
    http://comprarcialisgenerico40mg.com/ cialis venta
    http://cialis-achat.net/ cialis acheter
    http://kaufencialisgenerika20mg.net/ cialis generika

    ReplyDelete
  2. http://kaufencialisgenerika40mg.net/ cialis preise
    http://achat-cialis-pascher.net/ cialis commander
    http://acquistare-cialis-senzaricetta.net/ cialis comprare
    http://comprargenericocialisespana.net/ venta cialis

    ReplyDelete
  3. generic cialis order generic cialis cialis generique cialis cialis acquisto acquisto cialis cialis comprar cialis contrareembolso

    ReplyDelete
  4. cilias generic cilias generic prix cialis cialis medicament cialis cialis cialis comprar cialis online

    ReplyDelete
  5. http://cialisnopreascriptionmg.net/ buy cialis no preascription
    http://achatcialisgenerique20mg.net/ cialis generique
    http://acquistocialisgenerico20mg.net/ cialis costo
    http://comprarcialisgenerico20mg.net/ cialis venta

    ReplyDelete
  6. http://acheterviagragnerique1.net/ vente viagra
    http://comprarviagragenerico1.net/ viagra generico
    http://acquistareviagragenerico1.net/ viagra generico
    http://kaufenvaigragenerika1.net/ viagra

    ReplyDelete
  7. http://acheterviagragnerique1.net/ acheter viagra
    http://comprarviagragenerico1.net/ generico viagra
    http://acquistareviagragenerico1.net/ viagra
    http://kaufenvaigragenerika1.net/ viagra kaufen

    ReplyDelete
  8. http://buycheapcialisonline1.net/ cheap cialis
    http://prixcialisgenerique1.net/ commander cialis
    http://acquistocialisgenerico10mg.net/ dove acquistare cialis
    http://comprarcialisgenericoes10mg.net/ cialis venta

    ReplyDelete
  9. viagra achat generique viagra achat viagra generique viagra viagra comprar viagra original viagra viagra farmaco per impotenza

    ReplyDelete
  10. http://prixviagrageneriquefrance.net/ viagra
    http://commanderviagragenerique.net/ viagra commander
    http://viagracomprargenericoespana.net/ viagra sin receta
    http://acquistareviagragenericoitalia.net/ costo viagra

    ReplyDelete
  11. cialis commander cialis
    achat cialis cialis 20mg
    cialis cialis compresse
    cialis cialis precio farmacia

    ReplyDelete
  12. cialis generique cialis
    cialis generique prix cialis en pharmacie
    cialis generico cialis
    cialis comprar cialis farmacia

    ReplyDelete