Tuesday, 29 March 2011

Cambodia's Disabled Fight Poverty, Inequality


http://www.asiasentinel.com/

via CAAI

Written by Catherine Wilson
Monday, 28 March 2011

Landmine explosions/casualties still affect thousands

Cambodia remains littered with millions of unexploded devices left over from 30 years of civil war, the brutality of the Khmer Rouge and conflict with Vietnam.

The government itself believes that as many as 2 percent of the country's 14.7 million people are disabled with landmine casualties a significant proportion.

Poung Mai, who lost both legs when he stepped on a landmine, is one of those victims. He and Chhum Sopheap, who has suffered from polio, are seated on the ground in the midday sun next to the ticket kiosk inside the entrance gates to the National Museum in Phnom Penh with a basket of books to sell, each one carefully wrapped in plastic to lessen the inevitable damage from perpetual sun and dust.

They are among more than 60,000 physically disabled in Cambodia who struggle against poverty, discrimination, unequal access to education and employment and an under-funded and under-resourced state support system.

Cambodia is one of the poorest and most landmine contaminated countries in the world and the challenge of achieving economic inclusion, education and rehabilitation of the disabled is considerable. Numerous demining organisations, such as the Cambodian Mine Action Center, are steadily working to clear the country of millions of unexploded bombs and ordnances in rural regions, especially in the northwest close to the border with Thailand.

With 80 percent of the population residing in rural provinces, the prevalence of landmines has significantly reduced access to agricultural land, forests and water resources, and led to one of the highest rates of disability in the world as people in farming communities are maimed and killed as they go about their daily lives.

According to the Cambodia Mine Victim Information System (CMVIS), there were 286 landmine casualties in 2010, an increase on the 244 reported in 2009 and 271 in 2008, with 15 new casualties in January this year. It estimates that since 1979 there have been 63,821 mine casualties, which corresponds to 39 landmine deaths and injuries every week for 31 years, with about 44,000 survivors.

Poung Mai is from Prey Khmoa village in Prey Veng province where his family were rice farmers.

"During the civil war in Cambodia, the government [Khmer Rouge] arrested me and I was made to work in forestry, woodcutting," he said, "and then I stepped on a landmine." He was 28 years of age when both legs were amputated.

"After I stepped on the landmine, it was difficult," he continued, "I went around begging everywhere, at the market, to feed my family."

Poung has seven children. In 1990 he was removed by authorities to a center that provided food and shelter, but no prospect of livelihood. He subsequently left and found his way to Phnom Penh, where he continued to beg until he joined the Angkor Association for the Disabled in 2009, an organization of people with disabilities founded by Sem Sovantha, who suffered double amputation by a landmine, to provide shelter and training to members and campaign against discrimination.

Chhum Sopheap, also from Prey Veng province, came to Phnom Penh in 1997, sleeping on the streets until he started selling books at the National Museum in 2007.

Both say that the very small income they earn from selling books, on average $4.00 per day, enables them to rent a room and leave behind homelessness, which is often accompanied by alcoholism, mental ill-health, hunger and disease. Belonging to a disabled organization has also marginally improved their experience with the public, they say.

"When they are not with an association," Sem Sovantha explained, "there is a problem with the authorities. When they have an association, people will accept them and talk to them."
However, negative social attitudes and discrimination toward the disabled, such as physical harassment, social ostracism and economic exclusion, remain widespread.

Chhum claims that he mostly receives a positive response from visitors and tourists at the National Museum, "but the official in the area is not so happy about us, because he thinks it is not appropriate for us to be selling to tourists."

Local tour guides also attempt to dissuade visitors from being patrons.

"The customer would like to buy," Chhum explains, "but the customer believes the tour guide when he says ‘no, no', because at another shop the tour guide will get a commission."

According to a 2009 ILO report, "People with disabilities are among the most vulnerable groups in Cambodian society. They lack equal access to education, training and employment. While many workers with disabilities have considerable skills, many have not had the opportunity to develop their potential."

The Cambodian government introduced a Law on the Protection and Promotion of the Rights of People with Disabilities in 2009 to support the right to employment without discrimination, and in the same year adopted a National Plan of Action for Persons with Disabilities, including landmine survivors, in order to better address needs and provide services. The stated priorities of the Ministry of Social Affairs, Veterans and Youth Rehabilitation include strengthening and expanding welfare and rehabilitation services for the disabled, but, according to the Cambodian Disabled Peoples Organization, lack of human and financial resources has hindered real progress toward these goals, although the work of NGOs has resulted in the provision of more vocational training courses.

"Social acceptance and social attitudes toward disabled people and landmine amputees can be improved step by step through the Royal Government having a Disability Law and National Plan for persons with disability," a CDPO spokesperson said, "The problem in Cambodia is that we have the laws, but no budget to implement them."

In the meantime, Chhum Sopheap and Poung Mai strive to sell their books, many of which are biographies and stories of Cambodians, like themselves, who have struggled through the tragedy of the Khmer Rouge era and are determined to not only survive, but live to see a better future.

Khmer Rouge jailer Duch appeals against conviction

 via CAAI

By Guy De Launey
BBC News, Phnom Penh

28 March 2011


Comrade Duch argues the Khmer Rouge tribunal should not be judging him

A UN-backed tribunal in Cambodia is hearing the appeal of a former Khmer Rouge member who was convicted of crimes against humanity.

Kaing Guek Eav was in charge of a detention centre in the late 1970s and oversaw the deaths of around 15,000 people.

But now the man best known as Comrade Duch is arguing he should not have been tried at all.

The Khmer Rouge tribunal has a strictly defined role.

That is to bring to justice the surviving senior leaders of the Khmer Rouge and the people most responsible for the worst crimes committed during the four years Pol Pot's government controlled Cambodia.

Comrade Duch claims he falls into neither category.

Baffling

He has admitted that he ran the notorious S-21 detention centre in Phnom Penh.

During the public phase of his trial he even apologised to relatives of the people who died there.

But he insisted that he was only following orders and that he and his family might have been killed if he had not done as he was told.

The trial chamber rejected his arguments and passed a sentence of 35 years for crimes against humanity, torture and pre-meditated murder.

Youk Chhang is the director of the Documentation Centre which investigated the events at S-21.

He says Cambodians would be baffled by Duch's appeal.

"It's difficult for the public in general to understand the court procedure - they're not lawyers," he said.

"And it's because Duch himself has said all these things during the hearing already: 'Well, I admit it; now I don't'. And then people find that crazy."

The appeal hearing should be followed within months by the long-awaited second trial at the tribunal.

Four senior surviving Khmer Rouge leaders are facing charges of genocide for creating the policies which led to the deaths of around 2m people.

Lakeside residents seek meeting

Residents threatened with eviction from the Boeung Kak lake area protest outside City Hall in Phnom Penh on Friday.

http://www.phnompenhpost.com/

via CAAI

Monday, 28 March 2011 15:03 Chhay Channyda and Khouth Sophak Chakrya

Boeung Kak lake residents will once again seek a meeting with Phnom Penh Governor Kep Chuktema today, after being forcibly turned away by police during an attempt on Friday.

Lakeside residents submitted a written request for a meeting on Friday through the United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, seeking to discuss their proposal to set aside 15 hectares of the 133-hectare development for local villagers, and said City Hall had returned the letter with an official stamp.

Tep Vanny, a representative for more than 1,500 households facing eviction, said villagers would come to City Hall today seeking a response.

“This is the last chance for [Kep Chuktema] to demonstrate whether he is willing to meet and settle our problem or not,” Tep Vanny said.

“We will continue to ask for intervention from Samdech Prime Minister [Hun Sen] and relevant institutions if he still uses the excuse that he is busy resolving other affairs,” she said.

Kep Chuktema declined to comment yesterday.

On Friday, police armed with riot shields and electric batons subdued a protest by villagers, and hit and temporarily detained one woman.

Protester Kong Chantha said she nearly lost consciousness after a policeman elbowed her in the forehead and forced her into a police car.

She said three trucks of police, lead by Daun Penh district deputy governor Sok Penhvuth, had descended on the protesters, dispersing the crowd.

“Sok Penhuvuth’s subordinates arrested me as a weak woman protesting to ask for land and a house for my children. They seemed to think I was a prisoner because they caught me and put me into a prisoner car,” she said. “I didn’t rob anyone’s land. They are cracking down on me daily.”

Kong Chantha said she would file a complaint against the police over the incident. Sok Penhvuth declined to comment.

OHCHR staff, present to monitor the event on Friday, helped secure the release of Kong Chantha.

Christophe Peschoux, OHCHR country representative, said his office had written to city officials and the company developing the area, urging them to find a solution by meeting with villagers.

“Two weeks ago, we wrote to the mayor of Phnom Penh, Kep Chuktema, and we wrote to the head of Shukaku and encouraged them to meet with the community on the basis of the options opened by the municipality – either financial compensation, relocation, or on-site upgrading,” Peschoux said. “My understanding is that the community has opted for on-site upgrading.”

He said he has not yet received a response from city officials.

Additional reporting by Thomas Miller

No defence necessary: Sam Rainsy

http://www.phnompenhpost.com/

via VAAI

Monday, 28 March 2011 15:03 Thomas Miller and Meas Sokchea

Opposition leader Sam Rainsy said yesterday he will not ask his lawyer to defend him against charges of defamation and disinformation brought by Minister of Foreign Affairs Hor Namhong, in a case stemming from a 2008 complaint that the Phnom Penh Municipal Court announced last week it would hear on April 5.

Sam Rainsy, president of the eponymous political party, said yesterday he would not ask his lawyer to attend the trial “because it’s the same case with the same foregone conclusion”.

“As a matter of legal and judicial principle, nobody can be condemned twice for the same offence,” Sam Rainsy, who currently lives in self-exile in Paris, said by email.

The Municipal Court issued a summons on March 23 ordering Sam Rainsy to appear in court to face charges brought under Articles 62 and 63 of the UNTAC code.

In 2008, Hor Namhong filed a defamation lawsuit in France over a passage of Sam Rainsy’s autobiography, Rooted in Stone, which alleged that Hor Namhong headed the Boeung Trabek prison during the Khmer Rouge reign.

Sam Rainsy was fined and last year lost his appeal.

The Foreign Minister also filed suit in Cambodian courts in 2008 over a speech by Sam Rainsy that year delivered at the Choeung Ek “killing fields”, which referenced an alleged relationship between Hor Namhong and the Khmer Rouge leadership.

Deputy court prosecutor Ek Chheng Huot declined to comment yesterday and referred questions to Judge Seng Neang, who could not be reached.

Kar Savuth, Hor Namhong’s lawyer, could not be reached for comment yesterday.

The latest case against the embattled opposition leader complicates his appeal for a political settlement that would allow him to return to the Kingdom ahead of upcoming elections in 2012 and 2013.

Sam Rainsy faces a pair of jail terms totalling 12 years, handed down last year in connection with a protest he staged at the Vietnamese border in 2009. He was stripped of his parliamentary seat this month as a result of the convictions.

Ou Virak, president of the Cambodian Centre for Human Rights, said yesterday the charges were “mainly to pile up more pressure on Sam Rainsy not to return”, but not necessarily an indication that the government has ruled out a deal.

Sam Rainsy said “inevitable” political change in Cambodia would bring about a resolution.

“A political solution depends on the political situation. There will inevitably be an evolution in the political situation in Cambodia as shown and announced by recent and ongoing developments worldwide (Tunisia, Egypt, Libya, Yemen, Syria, etc),” Sam Rainsy said.

Health officials issue dengue fever warning

http://www.phnompenhpost.com/

via CAAI

Monday, 28 March 2011 15:01 Khoun Leakhana

Ministry of Health officials yesterday urged parents to take responsibility for protecting their children from dengue fever after the deaths of two children from the disease so far this year.

Cheamon Thavy, director of dengue fever health education at the National Centre for Parasitology, Entomology and Malaria Control at the Ministry of Health, said that some people do not follow health officials’ advice.

“[It is] hard to find a strategy to make them cooperate with us and due to this, a 5-year-old boy named Roeurn from Kandal province and 10-year-old Huon Sreyleak from Takeo province died from dengue fever this year,” said Cheamon Thavy.

Ngan Chantha, director of the National Anti-Dengue programme at the Ministry of Health, said that parents must protect their children from the disease.

“[Parents] must … monitor the environment around their home like rubbish, old tyres, coconut shells, cans or larvae and if there are those things around their home, they should spend time to clean it,” said Ngan Chantha.

According to the National Anti-Dengue programme, Phnom Penh, Kandal, Siem Reap, Kampot, Kampong Cham and Banteay Meanchey provinces are the most heavily affected by dengue fever.

Ou Sopha, program director for combating dengue fever at the Kandal provincial health department, said that the national authority would distribute the insecticide Abate within the six most infectious provinces.

According to the National Center for Parasitology, Entomology and Malaria Control there have been 231 cases of dengue fever in the first three months of this year resulting in two deaths, compared with 193 cases resulting in one death over the same period last year.

AKP - The Agence Kampuchea Press


via CAAI

Inter-Ministerial Working Group for Battlefield Information Coordination Established

Phnom Penh, March 28, 2011 AKP – The Royal Government of Cambodia last week set up an inter-ministerial working group to coordinate in providing and making public the information about and from the battlefield.

The Inter-Ministerial Working Group for Battlefield Information Coordination, established by the Royal Government of Cambodia’s Decision signed by Samdech Akka Moha Sena Padei Techo Hun Sen, the Prime Minister of the Kingdom of Cambodia, is composed of Gen. Neang Phat, Secretary of State to the Ministry of Defense, as Chairman; H.E. Phay Siphan, spokesman of the Press and Quick Reaction Unit, as permanent Vice-Chairman; and H.E. Koy Kuong, spokesman for the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation; and H.E. Chhum Socheat, spokesman for the Ministry of Defense, as Vice-Chairmen.

The Inter-Ministerial Working Group is tasked with duty and responsibility to coordinate and ensure the unity, effectiveness and order in providing or disseminating the information about and from the battlefield, concerned with political stability and national security.

It will coordinate with the public media and guarantee highly-effective flows of information, aimed at protecting national interests and maintaining military advantages and national security.

It will also make formal release of military, political and diplomatic information, and make appropriate examination and decision with quickness and punctuality on military, political and diplomatic information requested by the media for the permission to release.

The Inter-Ministerial Working Group may also form technical groups if necessary with members selected from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and International Cooperation, the Press and Quick Reaction Unit of the Council of Ministers, the Ministry of Information, the Units under the Ministry of Defense, the General Command, and the experts if needed. –AKP

By Ravuth M.

______

Cambodia, U.S. Open Workshop on MPAT TE-19

Phnom Penh, March 28, 2011 AKP – Cambodia’s Ministry of National Defense and U.S.’ Defense Department opened here last Wednesday a 10-day Workshop on Multinational Planning Augmentation Team Tempest Express 19.

The workshop was presided over by Cambodian Lieutenant General Nem Sovath, Director General of Cambodian Defense Ministry’s Department of Politics and Foreign Affairs and Mrs. Carol A. Rodley, U.S. Ambassador to Cambodia.

Addressing the workshop, Mrs. Rodley expressed her concern over the global catastrophe and terrorism at the sea, especially piracy.

The workshop has been attending by representatives from 23 countries, International Committee of the Red Cross, and UN’s agencies. –AKP

By KHAN Sophirom

______

NRK Staff Brings Home New Experience

Phnom Penh, March 28, 2011 AKP – Wider coverage via digital mode is one of the key experiences brought home by seven officials of the National Radio of Kampuchea (NRK) after their eight-day exposure visit to the Melbourne-based Australia Broadcasting Corporation in mid March 2011.

Sponsored by AusAid, the exposure visit allowed the seven Cambodian officials to different divisions and services of the Australia’s national public broadcaster, especially the Radio Australia.

“We have learned about how to build up listeners’ confidence on radio programme, especially the call-in show, in a manner that they can share issues happening in their community,” said Mr. Kry Chamroeun, head of Battambang provincial Information Department who led the delegation for the exposure visit.

Founded in December 1939, the Radio Australia started to host the programme in Khmer language 53 years later. It is now an NRK’s primary partner.

The 7th of its kind, this round of exposure visit gave chance to four staff from Battambang-based branch and three staff from NRK central office in Phnom Penh. –AKP

By MOM Chan Dara Soleil

______

Sovanna Komar Organization Provides More Than US$1 Million to Cambodia

Phnom Penh, March 28, 2011 AKP – Sovann Komar Children’s Village has provided US$1,157,100 for orphans and abandoned children in Cambodia.

The grant agreement was inked here on Mar. 25 by H.E. Hao Bun Se, Secretary of State at the Ministry of Social Affairs, Veterans and Youth Rehabilitation and Mr. Sothea Arun, Executive Director and co-founder of Sovanna Komar Children’s Village.

Some 100 Cambodian orphans and abandoned children will benefit from the project, which has started since Mar. 25, in accommodation, food, clothes, general education, English language, as well as other skills. –AKP

By LIM Nary

______

COMMENTARY: What ‘Secrets’ Is the Thai Government Protecting?

Phnom Penh, March 28, 2011 AKP – A day before the informal meeting of the ASEAN Foreign Ministers in Jakarta on 22 February, the Thai government asked Indonesia to send observers to the so-called disputed area near the Temple of Preah Vihear. The next day, in the presence of ASEAN Foreign Ministers from eight countries, the Thai government agreed to allow Indonesian observers to enter the area along the frontier line where deadly fighting between Cambodian and Thai armed forces erupted from 4 to 7 February.

Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Sen has clearly declared that on the Cambodian side of the frontier, Indonesian observers will have full freedom of access: “They can go anywhere, they can go any time, and they can see anything they want to see.” The Cambodian government responded promptly and positively to Indonesian letters involving the terms of reference for the observers. Even if Thailand rejects observers, Cambodia is willing to accept them unilaterally.

Indonesia initially proposed that the General Border Commission and Joint Boundary Committee meeting be held in Bogor on 24-25 March. This was later delayed to 7-8 April. But even these postponed meetings are now being objected to by the Thai Army Chief, Deputy Prime Minister in charge of security and Defence Minister, among others.

The Thai government doesn’t want the meetings to take place even though it had previously made the holding of these meetings a precondition for the deployment of the Indonesian observers agreed to on 22 February. And it doesn’t want any observers who can actually observe anything. Now, it has begun to let a little of its real intentions leak out.

MCOT online news reported on 23 March: “Thai army chief Gen Prayuth Chan-ocha on Wednesday said resolving the border conflict between Thailand and Cambodia will be more difficult if Indonesia sends observers into the disputed areas …”.

The same report continued: “The Thai army commander-in-chief expressed his disagreement following reports that Indonesian observers will enter the contested zone to observe the situation.” So, it seems that MCOT (which is 77 per cent owned by the Thai government) doesn’t know that its owner publicly asked for observers and then signed an agreement to that effect in Jakarta on 22 February. No, there are only “reports” that Indonesian observers might show up, and who knows where those “reports” might come from.

The Thai government is displaying its contempt for the opinions of ASEAN, the United Nations Security Council and the international community. Its arguments are so childish that it can hardly expect them to be taken seriously. No one has ever suggested that Indonesian observers would settle the problem created by Thailand’s recent claim over Cambodian territory. The reason for having observers is to report to the world who is responsible for any further outbreaks of fighting near the border — and thereby to prevent them.

The Thai government has already caused extensive damages to the Temple of Preah Vihear by its aggression against Cambodia. However, in defiance of the urging of the UN Security Council on 14 February for a permanent ceasefire and of the spirit of the ASEAN Foreign Ministers meeting and even of its own statement at that meeting, the Thai government continues its attempts to block every step towards preventing further armed clashes.

The Thai authorities initially began their delayed tactics to the deployment of the Indonesian observers they had agreed to by suggesting that there were military secrets that had to be protected. Next they insisted that there had to be meetings of the GBC and JBC before anything could happen. Now the GBC and JBC meetings can’t happen unless they are conducted in secret, with no neutral observers. That is the only way that the Thai government attempts to foul ASEAN, UNSC and international community in order to hide its most important secret about the situation on the border: that it is attempting to use military force to reverse the 1962 ruling of the International Court of Justice.

By Long Sokun
Researcher on the Case Concerning the Temple of Preah Vihear
(Cambodia vs. Thailand) 15 June 1962

(The comments are solely the opinion of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinion of the Royal Government of Cambodia.)

______

Cambodia To Construct Its Biggest Boulevard Ever

Phnom Penh, March 28, 2011 AKP –The biggest boulevard ever in the history of Cambodia will emerge in the southern part of Phnom Penh Capital in a few-year time and be named as Samdech Hun Sen Boulevard – a dedication to the rare leadership of Samdech Akka Moha Sena Padei Techo Hun Sen, the Prime Minister of Cambodia.

The three-year historic project has been officially agreed by the Royal Government of Cambodia and is undergoing feasibility study for the construction that will cost approximately US$36 million.

With 60 meter width and the length of more than nine kilometers, the Samdech Hun Sen Boulevard will link Street 271 of Phnom Penh to National Road 2 at Prek Ho district, Takhmao town of Kandal province. It is expected to contribute to solving the traffic congestion problem in the capital.

According to Phnom Penh Governor H.E. Kep Chutema, a thorough study is needed for the construction in order to ensure improved function of the two lakes that the Cambodia’s biggest boulevard will run across.

The two lakes, Boeung Tumpun and Boeung Choeung Ek, play a vital role to stock water from major sewage systems in Phnom Penh.

AZ TOWN company has been commissioned to construct the new boulevard. –AKP

By MOM Chan Dara Soleil

Four charged for drugs

http://www.phnompenhpost.com/

via CAAI

Monday, 28 March 2011 15:02 Buth Reaksmey Kongkea

Khiev Sanmon, acting secretary general of the National Authority for Combating Drugs, said yesterday that a Philippine national arrested last week for attempting to bring 3 kilograms of methamphetamine pills through Phnom Penh International Airport along with three others have been charged with drug offences.

Bookcilo Deyana, 26, a Philippine national, was arrested on March 21 after customs officials discovered the methamphetamine pills in her luggage, Khiev Sanmon said.

He added that Okere Ugochukwu Emmanuel, 30, president of the Nigerian Association of Cambodia, was arrested the following day based on information gathered from Deyana during questioning. Two Cambodian nationals identified as Mey Heng, 37, and Yim Rith, 40, were also detained on March 21 based on the same questioning.

“These people were officially charged [on Saturday]. The Nigerian man and the Philippine woman were charged with international drug trafficking, and the two Cambodian nationals were charged as accomplices,” Khiev Sanmon said.

He said all four suspects were in prison awaiting trial.

Ken Gaddafi, former president of the Nigerian Association of Cambodia, said yesterday that members of the association have had no contact with Emmanuel and little access to information about the case.

“We have yet to get any concrete facts about what transpired,” he said.

He warned, however, that the issue was a potentially damaging one for other Nigerian nationals living in Cambodia, who he said were often subject to generalisations about the alleged actions of individuals.

“The issue does not speak well for the Nigerian image,” he said, adding that much more information about the circumstances of the arrest of Emmanuel was needed.

Khiev Sanmon said that if convicted, the suspects could face up to 10 years in prison.

Villagers in Koh Kong locked in land dispute with Chinese firm

http://www.phnompenhpost.com/

via CAAI

Monday, 28 March 2011 15:02 Chhay Channyda

Villagers in Koh Kong province continued clashes on Friday with a Chinese company developing a multi-billion-dollar tourism project on the Kingdom’s coast with which they are locked in a land dispute.

Srey Mao, a resident of Koh Kong’s Botum Sakor district, said employees of Union Development Group were attempting to uproot fence posts on the land of roughly 40 families whose property overlaps with the project.

“Those who have had their fences removed have yet to receive any compensation,” she said.

Of the over 1,100 families that company and government officials have deemed affected by the project, only about 30 have yet to accept compensation, Koh Kong provincial deputy governor Sun Dara said.

Of the families that have moved, however, only 200 so far have received compensation, said In Kong Cheat, provincial coordinator for rights group Licadho. This compensation has come in the form of small plots of land six kilometres away in Thma Sar commune, he added.

Some of the affected families have homes on the site, which spans 36,000 hectares in Koh Kong’s Botum Sakor and Kiri Sakor districts, while others have farmland that overlaps with the project, said Neang Boratino, provincial coordinator for rights group Adhoc. Local military police have been working to provide “security” for Union Development workers, he added.

Neang Huot, 47, of Botum Sakor, said the compensation offer was inadequate because the plots are small and the area is unsuitable for farming.

“The government should help solve this issue for the people,” he said. “I have depended on my rice field, and now I am concerned that I will have nothing to feed my children.”

Villagers appeal to Hun Sen

http://www.phnompenhpost.com/

via CAAI

Monday, 28 March 2011 15:01 Khouth Sophakchakrya

Seventy-three families from Kampong Speu province’s Phnom Sruoch district yesterday appealed to Prime Minister Hun Sen to intervene with provincial authorities in Treng Trayeong commune to help them resettle after their houses were cleared on Friday.

Pheng Polin, one of the evicted villagers, said that only Hun Sen could intervene on behalf of villagers locked in a decade-long land dispute with petrol conglomerate Sokimex.

Evicted villager Sieng Sokha said that she and 20 other families were also banned from staying in nearby Treng Trayoeng pagoda.

Duch appeal to begin today

Former S-21 prison chief Kaing Guek Eav, better known as Duch, sits in the courtroom at the Khmer Rouge tribunal on the outskirts of Phnom Penh in July 2010. Appeals in Duch’s case will be heard at the tribunal starting today.

http://www.phnompenhpost.com/

via CAAI

Monday, 28 March 2011 15:02 James O’Toole and Cheang Sokha

The Khmer Rouge tribunal will convene today to hear appeals in the case of former S-21 prison chief Kaing Guek Eav, better known as Duch, who in July became the first defendant convicted by the court.

The prosecution, defence and a number of civil parties have all appealed the original judgment, in which Duch was found guilty of crimes against humanity and grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions, and sentenced to 30 years in prison. With credit for time already served, the 68-year-old now stands to spend roughly 18 more years in prison.

Duch’s trial began in 2009, with hearings stretching over roughly six months and dozens of witnesses and civil parties appearing. No new testimony will be heard this week, as the three planned days of hearings will instead focus on issues from the previous ruling including sentencing, reparations for civil parties and the jurisdiction of the court.

“These hearings will be very different from the Trial Chamber hearings, in the sense that it’s basically legal issues that are argued here,” United Nations court spokesman Lars Olsen said. “It’s not about factual findings at S-21.”

The defence has been granted the right to introduce new evidence during this week’s hearings, though this evidence will be limited to supporting their argument that Duch falls outside the court’s mandate to try “senior leaders” and those “most responsible” for Khmer Rouge atrocities and should therefore be released.

The defence first made this assertion during closing arguments in 2009, a stunning turnabout that followed months of hearings in which Duch had accepted responsibility and essentially pleaded guilty.

Observers say the Duch team’s arguments on this issue are weak and unlikely to be successful before the tribunal’s Supreme Court Chamber; at one point in their appeal brief, the defence lawyers reference a compendium of Cambodian folk tales to support a claim about criminal responsibility.

“I don’t think there’s a leg to stand on on this argument. It’s extremely weak,” said Anne Heindel, a legal adviser at the Documentation Centre of Cambodia. “They haven’t made any arguments that the sentence should be shorter – all their arguments are that the case should be dropped.”

The prosecutors, meanwhile, have called Duch’s original sentence “manifestly inadequate”, requesting in their appeal that the Khmer Rouge jailer instead receive a 45-year term, commuted from life in prison because of his excessive pre-trial detention following his arrest in 1999.

They also requested that “a further reduction be made as appropriate for the very limited mitigating circumstances” in the case, a reduction that co-prosecutor Andrew Cayley has said should be five years “at an absolute maximum”.

Civil party lawyers have also appealed, with some challenging the judges’ decision that their clients’ claims were inadmissible and others demanding more expansive reparations.

Today’s hearings will be devoted to the defence appeal and the issue of jurisdiction, while hearings on Tuesday will focus on sentencing and the prosecution appeal. Civil party issues will be discussed on Wednesday, with hearings extending into Thursday if necessary.

Court officials have said the Supreme Court will hand down a final judgment in the case by the end of June.

In the aftermath of the original verdict last year, a number of victims cried foul at the perceived brevity of Duch’s sentence, saying it was unacceptable for the head of a facility in which nearly all of the perhaps 14,000 inmates who entered were eventually killed.

S-21 survivor Vann Nath said yesterday that he was curious to see how many years Duch would ultimately receive, but that the most important thing was that the former warden had been found guilty.

“History will show that he has been found guilty,” Vann Nath said. “1,000 years later, his name will still be guilty.”

Centre sews seeds of change

http://www.phnompenhpost.com/

via CAAI

Monday, 28 March 2011 15:01 Post Staff

The Cambodia Skills Development Center recently held a graduation ceremony for students in two of its vocational training courses – pattern-making and production management for small and medium enterprises. Reporter Tom Brennan interviews one graduate about her experience.

Pin Phallah (right), head seamstress for the local boutique Spicy Green Mango, keeps a watchful eye over the production of clothes. Photo by: Tom Brennan

PIN Phallah runs a two-room sewing shop in Phnom Penh’s Toul Tom Poung commune where she and seven employees, all women from the neighbourhood, are responsible for most of the clothes sold at local boutique Spicy Green Mango.

As proud as the 43-year-old single mother is of her work, where she and her staff can turn out as many as 40 or 50 pieces of clothing a day, her shop isn’t quite where she’d like it to be.

Beyond the cramped workspace, Pin Phallah has, until recently, lacked the skills necessary to grow her business.

Like most Cambodian garment workers, she has known only “cut, make, trim”, which is just part of the entire manufacturing process. Nor has she had any formal methods for controlling costs, estimating prices or managing production.

Despite these obstacles, Pin Phallah seems focused on only one thing.

“I want a big business that has a lot of people” working for me, she said, standing outside her studio.

Spicy Green Mango owner Anya Weil wanted to grow her business without leaving Pin Phallah behind, so she reached out to the Cambodia Skills Development Center (CASDEC) for help.

She and CASDEC Director Tep Mona came up with a plan, part of which involved classes for Pin Phallah to take.

CASDEC is an NGO that provides training and consultancy services to the garment industry. The NGO is trying to help Cambodia compete for regional investment and jobs by developing the country’s companies and workforce.

Tep Mona has created two classes in particular: pattern-making, the first of its kind in Cambodia, and production management for small and medium enterprises.

Pattern-making will help to add a new element to Cambodia’s overall garment-making capabilities, Tep Mona said, while the latter course will teach workers all the different levels of the manufacturing process, whether it’s managing workers, estimating profit margins or simple housekeeping.

This will help the women get the jobs often held by visiting workers. As of 2007, the United States Agency for International Development found that foreigners accounted for 2 percent of the garment sector workforce but made up 10 percent of the total wages paid.

“So more and more investors can see [that] Cambodians are skilled now. They can do this and this and this and this. And [at] a much lower cost than other countries. So [investors] should come to Cambodia and invest in Cambodia’,” she said.

Most of the 32 students involved took one or the other of the classes, but Pin Phallah earned certificates in both.

Anya Weil has noticed a positive change in the interim.

“It really makes a big difference,” Weil said.

“I see her being much more confident in everything.” Other graduates of these courses have seen changes, too. Suon San, 27, used to be one of the Phnom Penh dump children targeted by French NGO Pour un Sourire d’Enfant, but now she works for PSE as a sewing manager.

At the graduation ceremony, she called the production management for SMEs class “very beneficial”, saying her operation, which makes clothes for the kids still collecting trash in order to survive, now boasts an assembly line process just like a professional factory.

Kuy Chenda, a 29-year-old assistant production manager for the Daughters of Cambodia’s sewing department, said the pattern-making class benefited more than just her.

“It’s very good not only for me, but also I can transfer the knowledge to others,” she said.

Still, there are limits to what students can achieve with just these two classes. And Tep Mona admits as much.

Few are ready to open their own shops, but they can at least work as a pattern-maker’s assistant.

Others, meanwhile, have merely added a bit of knowledge to their overall understanding of the industry.

Pin Phallah, though, seems determined. Thanks to the classes, she feels “better than before”, she said, and is ready to grow. Her plan now is to seek a loan from the bank and build above where she is based so as to escape the rains that often flood her workspace.

“Maybe two or three [more] floors,” she said.

Traders sour after export ban on limes

http://www.phnompenhpost.com/

via CAAI

Monday, 28 March 2011 15:00 Sieam Bunthy

THE export of Cambodian limes into Thailand was banned at Chom International Gate in Oddar Meancheay on Friday following chemical concerns, an official said.

Lime exports were halted due to accusations over the level of chemicals contained in the citrus fruit, said the Cambodian chief of the border gate Neth Dara.

He added Thai authorities were also asking traders to pay a 30 percent tax on the fruit.

Exporters, who deny that their fruit has been treated, say they have lost out.

Citrus trader So Rath said he normally brings untreated fruit from Chba Ampov commune, in Phnom Penh, to the border. He has in the past imported 25 tonnes of limes at one time and said the ban had so far lost him 10 million riel (US$2,479).

So Rath, along with officials, have strongly denied any concerns over the fruit.

“They do not want us to export because our lemons have sold well,” he said.

While Neth Dara claimed that Cambodian lemons were cheaper and of better quality than their Thai equivalents.

Hong Va, Camcontrol’s official at Chom International Gate, also claimed that natively grown limes were chemical free.

Mao Thora, secretary of state for Cambodia’s Ministry of Commerce, said that the ministry had yet to receive a complaint on the issue but would “cooperate with relevant institutions to solve [the issue] with Thailand”.

A representative from the Thai embassy in Phnom Penh was unavailable for comment last night.

Thailand plans trade mission to Cambodia

http://www.phnompenhpost.com/

via CAAI

Monday, 28 March 2011 15:00 Soeun Say

A GROUP of Thai businessmen have planned an investment and trade mission to Cambodia for the end of the month, officials at the Thai Embassy in Phnom Penh told The Post yesterday.

“There are 30 Thai businessmen visiting here on the 29th to the 31st,” said Jiranan Wongmongkol, commercial counselor at the Royal Thai Embassy. She added that the trip had been confirmed two weeks ago.

“They are coming here to look for opportunities to invest in agriculture and to export [Cambodian] rice to other countries in the world,” she said.

The Thailand Export Association will host investors seeking land to grow rice, cassava, corn and other agricultural products, as well as businessmen looking to enter the Kingdom’s rice export business.

The delegation plans to meet with Minister of Commerce Cham Prasidh, the Cambodian Rice Millers’ Associations, the Cambodian Chamber of Commerce and the state-owned Green Trade Company. “We try to do everything to attract Thai investors to invest in here,” Jiranan Wongmongkol said, “Such as our plan to do a trade fair two times this year.”

“We always told them about the real situation in here – which is that [Cambodia] is a] good, safe and confident [place] for them to invest,” she said.

Chan Nora, Secretary of State of the Ministry of Commerce, said yesterday that in general, Cambodia’s export to Thailand amount to only 1 percent of the Kingdom’s total, consisting of are mostly agriculture products.

Thai businesses have already invested in the retail, hotel and telecommunications sectors in Cambodia.

Signs that tourism is in for the long haul

http://www.phnompenhpost.com/

via CAAI

Monday, 28 March 2011 15:00 Steve Finch

THE scheduled arrival today of the first Air France flight to Phnom Penh in more than 35 years represents the first sign Cambodia is finally starting to establish itself as a long-haul destination in its own right, a key aim of the tourism industry.

When Air France’s Airbus A340-300 touches down in the capital today at about 2:30pm it will become the first major European airline to operate scheduled flights to Cambodia since the fall of the Khmer Rouge. And further intercontinental connections could follow.

Recent reports of talks between the government and Aeroflot point to possible flights to Russia, while the State Secretariat of Civil Aviation recently started talks with the United Kingdom and Turkey with the aim of setting up direct routes.

The key to developing new intercontinental routes will be whether airlines believe there is sufficient demand for scheduled services to Cambodia.

In Europe this certainly seems to be the case. In January, Europe was the fastest growing region as arrivals climbed 22 percent on a year earlier, Ministry of Tourism data showed. Over the same period, the number of Russian visitors more than doubled suggesting there is huge potential for Aeroflot flights.

One in every eight visitors to Cambodia now comes from Russia, the UK or France, a sign of how important the European market has become for the domestic tourism industry. The convenience of new, direct services to these countries is therefore vital if Cambodia is to tap into the fast-growing, high-spending European market.

Although Air France has finally returned to Cambodia, the fact its new scheduled services go through Bangkok is a reminder the country remains a spoke in world aviation connecting to more prominent hubs such as the Thai capital and Singapore. For Cambodia to really branch out its national carrier Cambodia Angkor Air would have to develop services beyond Asia, a possibility that appears some way off.

The Asia-Pacific region still accounts for two-thirds of all visitors to Cambodia including the top three destination countries, South Korea, Vietnam and China respectively.

Of the four airlines set to begin new connections to Cambodia during this year’s off-peak season, aside from Air France the rest are all within Asia. Airport operator Societe Concessionaire des Aeroports is scheduled to confirm flights by Tiger Airways to Singapore and Skywings Airlines on a new triangular route connecting Siem Reap, Seoul and Hanoi to add to Myanmar Airways International flights that started in February.

For many intercontinental airlines, connecting to Cambodia remains a leap of faith. But continued strong visitor growth suggests some long-haul carriers are starting to take the Kingdom seriously.

Out, dam spot, say rafters

Volunteers float down the Mekong River from Kampi to Kratie to raise awareness of threats posed by new dams upstream in Laos

Rafters launch at Kampi for their float downriver. Photo by: ZAC TIONGCO

http://www.phnompenhpost.com/

via CAAI

Monday, 28 March 2011 15:00 Laura Hodges

SCHOOL pupils and townspeople gathered to watch 21 people set off along the river from Kratie – accompanied by 20 police escorts – for a float down the Mekong River in inner tubes to raise awareness of dams and their consequences.

The group brought banners to parade from the pavilion along the riverside, before clambering into waiting tuk tuks and heading for the start of their flotilla at Kampi.

Accompanied by police and with their bright orange lifejackets serving as beacons, the convoy drew plenty of attention from villagers along the way last Thursday.

The diverse group of 21 people taking part in the 20km float included staff and volunteers from local NGOs Cambodian Rural Development Team and Community Economic Development, staff from international organisations VSO and IPADE, Kratie business owners and interested tourists.

“This is a great way to celebrate the river and have a great time with people who share the same ideas,” said Julie, a CRDT volunteer.

One of the organisers of the event, Walker Stephens, explained that the flotilla was to raise awareness of the proposed 1,200-megawatt Xayaburi Dam in Laos.

He drew attention to the seriously flawed environmental assessments, the dramatic impact on food security and its irreversibility, should construction take place. He also highlighted the impressive work of NGOs such as CRDT which bridges the gap between sustainable development and conservation.

Sun Mao, executive director of CRDT, emphasised the substantial impact the Xayaburi Dam would have on tourism in Kratie. He said each year 180,000 tourists came to Kratie each year to marvel at its unique biodiversity. “Today we will float amongst four of the world’s top six biggest freshwater fish, including the legendary Mekong catfish which is as big as a bear.”

Kampi’s chief of security, Pak Sokhan, said he feared that each year as the river level sank, there were fewer dolphins and would be fewer tourists if this continued.

Last week a letter was signed by 263 NGOs, from 51 different countries, calling for the cancellation of the Xayaburi Dam. The Mekong is the lifeblood for more than 60million people for jobs and fish, and irreversible changes to the Mekong’s ecology will push a number of species closer towards extinction, including the critically endangered Irrawaddy river dolphin.

Tola, one of the event’s organisers, said: “I have spent a lot of time taking tours along the Mekong and each time I feel that there is a union, a coming together of two forces.” Respect for the Mekong enables him to enjoy its beauty and adventure.

Before setting off from Kampi, Tola gave necessary safety instructions and everyone fitted their lifejackets. The first 10 minutes were full of laughter as everyone struggled to get into the float, but patience and persistence left the group easing along in the jet streams, avoiding the fast moving navigation columns from the French colonial era and swirling in the rapids.

Joining inner tubes together for the final push from Koh Trong to Kratie, The Mekong for Life event signified the united effort to celebrate the river and raise awareness of the detrimental consequences of the Xayaburi Dam. Despite some sunburn and one stubbed toe, the group is eagerly looking forward to the next float in 2012.

However, the 2 million employees of the US$300 million-a-year freshwater fisheries, and the 24 tourism boats at the dolphin pool in Kampi, await their fate. For more details, contact Walker Stephens at Mekongforlife@asia.com

Film stars join Earth Hour in Cambodia

Earth Hour Ambassador Tep Rindaro.


via CAAI

Monday, 28 March 2011 15:00 Post Staff

TWO of Cambodia’s most famous actors joined forces on Saturday to celebrate Earth Hour by switching off the lights for an hour to raise awareness of taking action for the planet.

Tep Rindaro, who began his film career in the 1980s, urged his fellow Cambodians to help make a difference by taking actions to save power in everyday life.

The businessman and legendary actor joined Yuthara Chhany, one of the most famous faces in Cambodia’s film industry and vice-president of Cambodian Artists’ Association, as Earth Hour Ambassador.

Groups across the world celebrated Earth Hour by switching off their lights for one hour at 8.30pm in their local time zones.

About 60 businesses and restaurants in Phnom Penh joined the efforts, including several international hotels and riverside eateries.

“As individuals, we can do our own little part to reduce the amount of CO2 released into the atmosphere and take action on climate change for 365 days,” said Yuthara Chhany.

Earth Hour is the world’s largest environmental movement which encourages individuals to make a small change for a positive impact, and is supported by WWF in Cambodia.

Monday, 28 March 2011

Corn on the Cambodian cob suits Korean farmer

Lee Woo-chang, head of KomerCN, examines corns grown at his farm in Cambodia. Provided by the company


via CAAI

March 28, 2011

Lee Woo-chang, 42, set up a farming company called KomerCN in Cambodia back in December 2008 to grow corn. Lee started out small. His initial farm was on 21 hectares (51.89 acres) of land in Wiwalton Village, Kampong Speu Province. However, he wants to expand the farm to 13,000 hectares.

Lee also formed a corn agricultural cooperative with 1,400 Cambodian farmers who are cultivating 7,000 hectares of land. Lee plans to purchase all the corn produced by the cooperative and export it to Korea, which is heavily dependent on corn imports.

According to Lee, it will be one of the first times that Korea has imported corn from a Korean-managed overseas farm.

Lee is in talks with Daesang, a major local food producer, for the Cambodian corn supplies. “If the corn is tested to be safe from toxins or molds, it may happen,” Lee said.

Daesang buys 500,000 tons of corn a year. KomerCN and Daesang are now doing a field study of the farm.

“This is a feat achieved only two and a half years after we entered Cambodia,” Lee said.

Lee started looking outside Korea in 2007 when the international price of grain began shooting up. Lee was originally a livestock farmer, owning a large cattle farm in Asan, South Chungcheong.

But the price of animal feed, including corn, increased so much that he decided to start his own farm outside Korea. The prices kept raising and the feed was not only expensive but also hard to get.

“I thought if I go overseas and do farming myself, I could at least get a stable supply of grain,” he said.

In May 2008, Lee joined a government program and went to Cambodia to check out farming conditions there. Lee chose Cambodia because of the weather. The area’s average temperature is around 30 degrees Celsius (86 degrees Fahrenheit). Except for the dry season between November and March, it is possible to have three rounds of harvests a year. “The Russian Far East is too cold. I thought it would be more productive to do farming in Cambodia,” Lee said.

Cambodia covers 181,040 square kilometers (44.7 million acres) of land and is twice as large as South Korea (99,000 square kilometers). However, the population is only 15 million and unlike China and Russia, there is less likelihood that Cambodia may limit grain exports. The fact that teenagers and young adults make up a large portion of its population is also a plus.

“There are a lot of human resources. Because manufacturing has not yet developed much, farming is still a major source of income in Cambodia,” he said.

In December 2008, he invested 2.5 billion won ($2.2 million) including 800 million won he borrowed from the Ministry for Food, Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries and founded a company, which he named “KomerCN,” a combination of Korea and Khmer, the old name of Cambodia.

Wiwalton is a remote village with 30,000 people. There is no reservoir or electricity. Lee spent six months of the year there starting to develop the farm. He has imported a total of 69 tons of corn from Cambodia to Korea so far.

Of course, the project is not without difficulties. Because of the high humidity and temperature, corn becomes easily molded. A large amount of corn is wasted because of the toxin from mold.

“We are now building a drying storage facility. When it is completed in June, we’ll no longer need to worry about mold,” he said. South Chungcheong provided 39 million won for the facility.

In July 2009, Lee and local residents formed a farming cooperative association. Lee gave them corn seeds and taught them how to grow corn. The number of cooperative members increased rapidly as Lee promised to purchase all harvested corn. Now it has 1,400 members and the number is expected to reach 3,000 next month.

“Buying and cultivating lands on one’s own can be stable but it costs too much money,” said Cho Rae-cheong, a deputy director at the Agriculture Ministry. “It is a good idea to spread the risks by purchasing from the cooperative.”

“The price of grain surged in 2008 and some 50 companies went abroad to establish overseas food production bases but they have exported only a small amount of grain to Korea,” said a ministry official. “But large exports will help stabilize food prices here.”

By Lim Mi-jin, Limb Jae-un [jbiz91@joongang.co.kr]

Khmer Rouge jailer's war crimes appeal to begin

A Cambodian woman point to a portrait of former Khmer Rouge prison chief (S21) Kaing Guek Eav, better known as Duch

via CAAI

By Suy Se (AFP) –
PHNOM PENH — Lawyers for former Khmer Rouge prison chief Duch will call for his release on Monday when Cambodia's UN-backed war crimes court begins hearing appeals against his 30-year sentence.

Duch, whose real name is Kaing Guek Eav, was found guilty in July of war crimes and crimes against humanity for overseeing the deaths of some 15,000 people at the notorious torture prison Tuol Sleng in the late 1970s.

He was the first Khmer Rouge cadre to face an international tribunal.

During his trial, the jailer repeatedly apologised for overseeing mass murder at the detention centre -- also known as S-21 -- but shocked the court by finally asking to be acquitted in November 2009.

In their appeal hearing on Monday, Duch's lawyers plan to argue that the court has no jurisdiction over their client because he was not one of the regime's senior leaders, nor one of those most responsible for the crimes committed.

"The court is not allowed to try a person that does not fall into one of those two groups," defence lawyer Kang Ritheary told AFP, adding that Duch was only following orders.

The 68-year-old was initially given 35 years in jail but the court reduced the sentence on the grounds that he had been detained illegally for years.

Taking into account time already served, Duch could walk free in less than 19 years, to the dismay of many victims of the 1975-1979 hardline communist movement.

Prosecutors, whose appeal will be heard on Tuesday, are hoping to have Duch's sentence increased to life, to be commuted to 45 years for time served in unlawful detention.

They say in their appeal brief that the verdict did "not adequately reflect the seriousness of the crimes or the respondent's role in those crimes".

They also want enslavement, imprisonment, torture, rape, extermination and other inhumane acts to be added to Duch's list of convictions.

The tribunal's Supreme Court Chamber is expected to announce its ruling on the appeals in late June.

Led by "Brother Number One" Pol Pot, who died in 1998, the Khmer Rouge wiped out nearly a quarter of Cambodia's population through starvation, overwork and execution.

S-21 in Phnom Penh was at the centre of the regime's security apparatus and thousands of inmates were taken from there for execution in a nearby orchard.

Duch has been detained since 1999, when he was found working as a Christian aid worker in the jungle. He was formally arrested by the tribunal in July 2007.

Four more of the regime's former members -- including "Brother Number Two" Nuon Chea -- are due to go trial later this year and Duch is expected to appear as a witness in the case.

The zoo of horrors

Photo by: Adam Miller
An emaciated elephant attempts to eat grass by poking her head through the fence of a pen where she is confined at Teuk Chhou Zoo in Kampot province’s Thmei Village.


via CAAI

Sunday, 27 March 2011 21:09 Adam Miller

Kampot province’s Teuk Chhou zoo is a place where no one seems to care about how animals are treated, a place where animals are kept in cramped, roofless shelters and rely largely on food from tourists to survive.

The zoo is privately owned by Cambodia’s National Committee for Disaster Management Vice President Nhim Vanda and staffed by just a handful of people.

It has no roofed-in shelters as the wet season approaches or even any semblance of a natural habitat for the animals as witnessed during a visit over the weekend.

Orangutans and baboons swing restlessly back and forth between the steel bars of their three-metre square enclosures, while eagles and other birds of prey scarcely have enough space to spread their wings, let alone fly – that is if they are one of the lucky few whose wings aren’t badly damaged.

The state of the zoo’s two elephants is heartbreaking, as their emaciated necks stretch through the thick bars of their enclosure in an attempt to eat blades of grass, seemingly one of their few sources of nourishment.

The skeletal bodies of the two animals are hard to ignore and the two have become aggressive, lashing out at visitors who step near their enclosure.

“We feed them bananas and grass,” said a staff member who declined to be named or to comment further.

Yet the elephant enclosure contained only dried-up bamboo shoots, piles of faeces and a pit of stagnant green drinking water that the elephants avoided.

When initially asked about conditions at the zoo last Thursday, Nhim Vanda acknowledged that some of the animals were “thin and sick”, but the zoo would remain “operating as usual”, with an entrance fee of US$4.

Nhim Vanda condemned local NGO Wildlife Alliance today for past criticisms about his zoo and said he paid for the care of his animals out of his own pocket.

“If they know that my animals have gotten thin ... please give me the money to buy food for my animals. They should be proud of me and encourage me because I like my animals more than my own son.”

He also said there was no government policy to provide monetary support to the privately owned facility.

“It is so hard for me to find food and clean water to provide to the animals because in one day I get money from tourists totalling about 20,000 riel (US$5) to 100,000 riel but I pay much more than that for food,” he said.

Nick Marx, wildlife rescue director at Wildlife Alliance, said yesterday that his organisation had previously assisted the zoo.

“We have helped out in Teuk Chhou zoo before and have paid money for food and medicine for animals,” Marx said.

“We even paid for treatment for one of their elephants when it was seriously injured … the problem is that we
don’t have the money to help extensively.”

He said some members of Wildlife Alliance’s rapid-rescue team went to the zoo last week to assess conditions and he concluded that it was “the same as it has always been”.

“Nhim Vanda I’m sure loves his animals, but apparently doesn’t have enough money to support them is what we’re told,” Marx said.

“If it was a question of helping the animals, we would take what we can [to Phnom Tamao zoo], but I can’t give thousands of dollars, I just do not have the money to give.”

There has been some conjecture about the number of animals who may have died at Teuk Chhou zoo over the years.

Marx said it remained unclear what happened to the tiger cubs once at the zoo and that a few years ago there were five bears there.

An otter photographed by a visitor and posted on local website Khmer 440 on March 9 shows the mammal in a sickly state, struggling to breathe while covered in green scum from its only source of water.

On Friday there was merely an empty enclosure where the otter once lived.

“Before there were a lot of animals to see, now they’re all gone, I don’t know why,” said Sokna, a nearby resident.

His girlfriend, Chanthy, concurred, saying: “We came to look at all of the animals but there is nothing left.”

In a four-hour period on Friday, they were the only two visitors to the zoo.

The Ministry of Tourism’s website describes the zoo as “a wonderful place to spend a fun-filled afternoon with your family; children especially love the experience”, adding that the zoo featured lions and tigers and their cubs.

Yet only one tiger remains in a small cage bereft of any cubs, while no lions could be found in the larger enclosed space designated for them.

It also said that the zoo included “bears, including a couple of sun bears”, yet only one bear remains at the zoo.

Jack Highwood, head of the NGO Elephants Livelihood Initiative Environment who runs the Elephant Valley Project sanctuary in Mondulkiri province, told The Post on Friday that “elephants aren’t meant to walk the streets of Phnom Penh, or circle Angkor Wat, or live in a zoo”.

A place like his sanctuary in Mondulkiri is more like “their natural habitat. We have a huge area of land here. This is where they are meant to be”.

With regard to the Teuk Chhou zoo, Highwood said: “While I can’t comment on the specifics of this case, here at the EVP we welcome any elephants from any zoo.”

Alma Robinson, a volunteer at the EVP who spent three months working with elephants in Mondulkiri earlier this year, gave a first-hand account of what she had seen in February on a trip to the zoo in Kampot.

“It is now six weeks since I last visited Teuk Chhou Zoo and I am still haunted by what I saw,” she said on Thursday.

“In the midst of all of the surrounding green and beautiful natural habitat I was shocked to find what I can only call ‘a concrete prison’ not only for the two elephants but for all of the animals.

“Small, dirty enclosures – cages lacking clean water – in some cases no water at all and no sign or even remnants of food. My heart went out to these poor, suffering and traumatised animals.”

She said the state of the elephants was of particular concern and their struggle to survive on a day-to-day basis was horrific.

She described their enclosure as “a pathetic, distressing, shocking scene indeed which needs to be brought to the attention of the Cambodian people”.

If the zoo management does not have the financial stability to maintain the facility and the animals in its care, then a high-level investigation must be undertaken by the government and drastic action is warranted.